California Court Rules Against Personal Injury Lawsuit, Upholds Workers’ Comp Exclusivity
April 15, 2025 | MedLegalNews – Contract Term Limits Comp: In a recent ruling, a California appeals court determined that a skylight installer injured on the job cannot pursue a personal injury lawsuit against the general contractor. Instead, the installer must rely solely on workers’ compensation benefits—reinforcing the exclusive remedy doctrine under California labor law.
Injury Occurred on Job Site, But Tort Claims Denied
The case involved an independent subcontractor who fell through a skylight while working on a roofing project. He sustained serious injuries and later sued the general contractor for negligence. However, the court found that the worker had been contracted for a long enough period—over two days—to qualify as a “special employee” under Labor Code § 2750.5. Contract Term Limits Comp
Because of this classification, workers’ compensation coverage became the exclusive legal remedy, eliminating the option for a civil lawsuit.
Court Analyzes Duration and Control
The court closely examined factors such as the duration of the worker’s engagement, the general contractor’s degree of supervision, and whether the job fell within the normal course of business. In this case, the contractor exercised enough control over the worker’s schedule and duties to meet the legal definition of an employer.
Ultimately, the court ruled that the installer had no valid claim for damages outside of the workers’ compensation system.
Legal Implications for Employers and Contractors
This decision reinforces the importance of understanding how employment classification and duration can impact legal liability. General contractors should be aware that even short-term workers may be considered employees under the law if supervision and work integration criteria are met.
Meanwhile, injured subcontractors must evaluate their options carefully and consult a qualified attorney to determine whether they fall under exclusive remedy protections or can pursue third-party claims.
For more information on employment classifications and comp law nuances, visit our Workers’ Comp section.
🔗 Full opinion available from the California Courts
Read More from MedLegalNews.com
- Construction Company Cited $157,500 After Fatal Trench Collapse
- Support Fire Recovery Efforts: California Invests $25 Million
- California Lawmakers Demand Answers Over $3.44 Billion Medi-Cal Loan
- DWC Posts Reminder for RTWSP Application Requirements
- CA Insurance Commissioner Reappoints Two to WCIRB Governing Committee