California Workers’ Comp Deposition Fee Proposal Draws Criticism From Both Sides

November 16, 2026 | Sacramento, CA — MedLegalNews.com — California’s deposition fee proposal is drawing significant attention across the workers’ compensation system as regulators consider statewide limits on hourly compensation for attorneys representing injured workers during depositions. The proposed regulation seeks to establish a more consistent method for determining reasonable attorney fees when employers or insurers request depositions involving injured employees or individuals claiming dependent benefits. However, the proposed rates and restrictions have generated objections from both applicant attorneys and insurance industry representatives, exposing competing concerns about fair compensation, litigation expenses, and billing oversight.

The California Division of Workers’ Compensation (DWC) is considering maximum hourly rates ranging from $350 to $500, depending on an attorney’s experience and professional certification. Supporters of standardized rates may view the proposal as a way to reduce disputes and improve predictability in deposition-related payments. Critics, however, argue that the proposed structure could either undervalue experienced legal representation or create opportunities for excessive billing, depending on how the final regulation defines compensable work and enforces its requirements. Because the informal comment period has closed, the next significant step is formal rulemaking, which must include another opportunity for public participation before permanent regulations can be adopted.

Proposed Hourly Rates and the Structure of the Regulation

The deposition fee proposal establishes a tiered compensation framework based on an attorney’s experience and certification. Under the version described in the November 2026 reporting, certified workers’ compensation specialists could receive up to $500 per hour. Attorneys with at least 10 years of experience would have a proposed maximum rate of $450, while those with five to 10 years of experience would be subject to a $400 maximum. Attorneys with fewer than five years of experience would fall under a proposed $350 hourly ceiling. The structure attempts to recognize differences in professional experience while creating a statewide reference point for determining reasonable deposition-related fees.

The proposed rates are maximums rather than guaranteed payments. Establishing an hourly ceiling does not necessarily mean that every deposition will qualify for compensation at the highest applicable rate. The amount ultimately payable may depend on the work performed, the attorney’s qualifications, the circumstances of the deposition, and the requirements established in the final regulation. This distinction is important because the deposition fee proposal is intended to address the reasonableness of attorney compensation, not simply establish an automatic payment entitlement for every hour claimed. Regulators will need to clarify how the rate categories operate in practice and what documentation will be required to support a fee request.

Applicant Attorneys Challenge the Proposed Compensation Limits

Attorneys representing injured workers have raised concerns that the proposed rates do not adequately reflect the cost of providing legal representation in California. Their objections include inflation, increased operating expenses, staffing costs, professional liability expenses, and differences in the cost of maintaining a legal practice across the state. Some attorneys have argued that the proposed maximums should be increased to $600 or $650 per hour. Others have recommended annual cost-of-living adjustments to prevent the rates from becoming outdated as economic conditions and professional expenses change. These concerns reflect the position that deposition representation requires specialized knowledge and preparation that should be compensated at a reasonable level.

Another point of disagreement involves the relationship between certification and experience. Under the proposed structure, certified workers’ compensation specialists would qualify for the highest hourly maximum. Some commenters have argued that attorneys with extensive workers’ compensation experience should also qualify for the top rate even if they do not hold the specified certification. Their position is that years of practice, familiarity with medical records, knowledge of workers’ compensation procedures, and experience handling complex claims may demonstrate professional competence. The deposition fee proposal will therefore require regulators to consider whether certification alone provides a sufficient basis for the highest compensation tier or whether other forms of documented experience should be recognized.

Travel Time and Transcript Review Raise Additional Concerns

The proposal also addresses compensation for travel time and deposition transcript review. Under the described framework, payment for these activities would be limited to 50% of the applicable hourly rate. This approach attempts to distinguish direct deposition participation from other work associated with the proceeding. However, applicant attorneys have argued that travel and transcript review involve professional time and may be essential to effective representation. Travel may be necessary when a deposition takes place outside an attorney’s office or requires attendance at a location selected by the requesting party. Transcript review can also be important for identifying inaccurate testimony, evaluating inconsistencies, and preparing for subsequent litigation activity.

The disagreement raises a broader question about how regulators should define reasonable deposition-related services. A deposition does not begin and end with the attorney’s attendance at the proceeding. Preparation, review of relevant records, travel, communication with the client, and examination of the transcript may all contribute to effective representation. At the same time, insurers and employers have a legitimate interest in ensuring that billed activities are necessary, sufficiently documented, and reasonably connected to the deposition. The deposition fee proposal will need to distinguish legitimate professional work from duplicative or administrative activity. Clear definitions could reduce disagreements about what is compensable and make payment decisions more predictable for both sides.

Insurers and Employers Question Billing Controls

Insurance carriers and employer representatives have raised a different set of concerns. Their objections focus on the possibility that statewide hourly maximums could increase costs or encourage excessive billing if the regulation does not clearly identify which activities qualify for reimbursement. Some industry representatives have urged the DWC to reinstate restrictions on compensation for administrative tasks and clarify the types of deposition preparation that may be billed. Other recommendations include limiting compensable deposition preparation to one hour, requiring attorneys to document their experience, and requiring billing requests to be submitted under penalty of perjury.

These comments reflect the importance of accountability in any fee framework. A maximum hourly rate alone does not determine whether the time claimed was reasonable or whether the work was necessary. Regulators may need to establish documentation standards that allow insurers to evaluate billing requests without creating unnecessary procedural disputes. Requirements identifying the attorney’s qualifications, the activity performed, the time spent, and the connection to the deposition could improve transparency. The deposition fee proposal must balance reasonable compensation with safeguards against unsupported charges. If the final regulation leaves key billing questions unresolved, disputes may continue even after statewide rates are established.

Payment Delays and Enforcement Remain Unresolved Issues

One recurring concern among applicant attorneys involves the absence of specific payment deadlines and penalties for insurers that delay paying deposition-related attorney fees. Commenters have argued that maximum rates will not fully resolve compensation disputes if there is no clear process requiring timely payment. Delays may create additional administrative work for law firms and lead to further disagreements between attorneys and claims administrators. From the perspective of injured workers’ representatives, a fee framework should address not only the amount payable but also the procedure and timeframe for payment.

This issue is particularly important because the regulation concerns fees that employers or insurers are responsible for when they request depositions under applicable California workers’ compensation law. If the final rule establishes compensation limits but does not adequately address payment procedures, parties may continue to dispute whether a charge was properly submitted, when payment is due, and what remedy applies when payment is delayed. The deposition fee proposal could therefore benefit from clearer administrative requirements, including deadlines, notice procedures, and a defined process for resolving contested billing requests. Whether the DWC adopts such provisions remains a matter for the formal rulemaking process.

October Revisions and the Next Rulemaking Stage

The DWC’s October revisions modified several elements of the regulations initially proposed in February 2026. According to the November reporting, the revised version removed proposed restrictions on compensation for certain deposition-related activities, eliminated incremental billing requirements, and dropped a proposed $250 cap for non-attorney representatives. These changes indicate that the proposal has evolved following consideration of concerns raised during the regulatory process. They also demonstrate that the initial version should not be treated as the final regulatory position.

The informal public comment period closed on November 9, 2026, after the division received comments from attorneys, insurers, and industry organizations. The closure of that forum does not mean the regulation has been adopted. The DWC must initiate formal rulemaking, which includes publication of the proposed regulatory language, another public comment period, and a hearing before permanent regulations can be finalized. Participants will have another opportunity to evaluate the revised language and submit formal objections or recommendations. The deposition fee proposal remains subject to that process, and the final provisions may differ from the version currently under discussion.

Potential Effects on California Workers’ Compensation Proceedings

The eventual regulation could influence how attorneys, insurers, and employers budget for deposition-related expenses in California workers’ compensation proceedings. Depositions are an important part of the discovery process, allowing parties to obtain testimony, clarify disputed facts, and develop evidence relevant to claims. Injured workers may be asked to testify about their injuries, treatment history, employment circumstances, and other issues affecting their claims. When an employer or insurer requests a deposition, the applicable rules governing reasonable attorney fees help determine how the injured worker’s legal representation is compensated for participation.

For attorneys, standardized rates could make fee expectations more predictable, but the practical effect will depend on the final rate structure and definitions of compensable services. For insurers and employers, clearer billing standards may support more consistent review of deposition expenses. For injured workers, the issue has an indirect but important connection to access to representation during proceedings that may affect their benefits and claims. The deposition fee proposal should therefore be evaluated not only as a cost-control measure but also as a procedural rule affecting the balance between reasonable legal compensation and responsible claims administration. The final regulation will need to account for these competing interests without creating unnecessary barriers to effective representation or legitimate oversight.

Review the California Division of Workers’ Compensation for official regulatory notices, proposed rulemaking materials, public hearing information, and updates concerning workers’ compensation regulations.


Subscribe to MedLegalNews.com for accurate coverage of California workers’ compensation regulations, medical-legal developments, claims administration, and policy changes affecting injured workers and industry professionals.


🔗 Read More from MedLegalNews.com:

FAQs: California Workers’ Compensation Deposition Fee Proposal

What hourly rates does the California deposition fee proposal establish?

The proposal describes maximum hourly rates ranging from $350 to $500, depending on attorney experience and certification. Certified workers’ compensation specialists could qualify for up to $500 per hour, while other experience tiers have proposed maximums of $450, $400, and $350. These are proposed limits, not guaranteed payments or an adopted statewide fee schedule.

Why are applicant attorneys opposing the proposed rates?

Some applicant attorneys argue that the proposed rates do not adequately account for inflation, operating expenses, and the cost of specialized workers’ compensation representation. They have also raised concerns about reduced compensation for travel and transcript review, the treatment of experienced attorneys without certification, and the lack of payment deadlines or penalties for delayed payments.

Why do insurers and employers oppose parts of the proposal?

Insurance and employer representatives have expressed concern that the proposed rates could encourage excessive billing without clear restrictions on compensable activities. Their recommendations include stronger documentation requirements, limits on administrative charges, clearer definitions of deposition preparation, and verification of attorney experience and billing requests.

Has the DWC adopted the deposition fee proposal?

No. The informal comment period has closed, but the DWC must still initiate formal rulemaking, including another public comment period and a hearing, before permanent regulations can be adopted. The proposed rates and other provisions should not be treated as final requirements.

Scroll to Top